Did we even know what we were watching at the time? The lovable Labrador/Mastiff may have been an early pioneer for helping us all learn to sympathize and to understand mental health.
SPOILER ALERT: I guess it should be established now that this post will spoil the end of 1957’s Old Yeller. This is one of those movies that most of us know the ending to anyway, but just in case you want to see this one without knowing how it ends, proceeding from here will make that impossible.
It’s an unforgettable story that’s hard not to love. The titular character is a loyal family dog who not only offers unconditional love, he also protects the family from the likes of bears, wolves, and wild hogs. “The best doggone dog in the west” is the ideal of the perfect pet. He’s the dog your grandparents had on their farm. The dog you could always count on to be a good boy. This is what makes the end of his story so conflicting for us. While saving the family from a rabid wolf, the dog is bitten several times. This inevitably leads to Old Yeller contracting rabies himself, and becoming the antithesis of what he was. Now he is ferocious, mad, dangerous.
Many adults identify this film as the most emotional movie of their childhood. If you thought The Lion King, Bambi, and Up had soul-crushing scenes, Old Yeller makes them look like a walk in the park. As a child I was truly torn. In a little over an hour I had a love for that dog as if it was my own for the last ten years. But I knew that if there was no magical cure, Travis had to do what he had to do. I hated that this was the only option. But it was. Without “putting him down,” Yeller would now more likely kill a child than save one.
But it wasn’t the dog’s fault! No, it wasn’t. He wasn’t doing anything wrong to put himself in this situation that brought upon him the disease; he was heroically rescuing a family! As a child I saw that snarling, barking dog and felt fear first, then compassion. It’s not him. It’s his sickness.
This is a perfect picture of the emotional wrestling match we find ourselves in when seeing someone we love becoming consumed by a failing mental health condition. Sadly, when it’s someone we are not connected to, it’s much easier to judge. When Charlie Sheen spends millions on gambling and doesn’t pay child support, or Tiger Woods cheats on his wife, or Lindsay Lohan is caught intoxicated in public, none of us want to hear the word addiction to describe their situation. Sure, it’s easier to have compassion on, say, a person who becomes addicted to pills that were prescribed to them. But the sickness is the same. And how do we know the full story on anybody’s emotional and/or mental breakdown?
The sickness doesn’t justify the behaviour, but seeing it as a result of a bigger problem gets us on the road to helping and preventing instead of just shaking our heads and tsk-ing. Unlike in the case of Old Yeller, there are things that can be done to bring healing and restitution. Metaphorically “shooting” the person who is self-destructing isn’t the only option we have for making things right. What would you want someone to do if you were in such dire straits?
Sometimes watching those difficult scenes in movies help us grow. So remember Old Yeller. The way it tore your heart in two can make you wish you hadn’t watched, but it can also make you self reflect and become a better person.
Congratulations Old Yeller. This is your week.
And the Oscar goes to…
Best Actress: Helena Bonham Carter as Lady Campanula Tottington in W&G: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit
Best Actor: Tom Hanks as Scott Turner in Turner and Hooch.
Best Quote: “I’m sorry, Gromit. I know you’re doing this for my own good, but the fact is I’m just crackers about cheese.” — Peter Sallis as Wallace in W&G: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit
When it comes to movie dogs, sometimes the likes of Benji, Lassie, Beethoven, Bud, and Toto steal the limelight and overshadow some true greats. So…
Top 10 Movie Dogs who deserve more attention:
- Hercules, The Sandlot (1993)
- Max’s Dog, Mad Max 2 (1981, aka The Road Warrior)
- Fly, Babe (1995)
- The Alaskan Malamute, The Thing (1982)
- Bruiser, Legally Blonde series (2001, 2003)
- Brandy, Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood (2019)
- Unnamed rottweiler, Ferris Bueller’s Day Off (1986)
- Milo, The Mask (1994)
- Einstein, Back to the Future (1985)
- Hachi, Hachi: A Dog’s Tale (2009) — If you like dog movies at all, I swear you’ll love this one. It’s a very underappreciated Richard Gere movie.
And the Animated Edition:
- Chief, The Fox and the Hound (1981)
- Percy, Pocahontas (1995)
- Fifi, Open Season (2006)
- Zero, The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)
- Charlie B. Barkin, All Dogs Go to Heaven (1989)
- Wylie Burp, An American Tail: Fievel Goes West (1991)
- Pooka, Anastasia (1997)
- Peg, Lady and the Tramp (1955)
- Footstool, Beauty and the Beast (1991)
- All the dogs on Isle of Dogs (2018)